Reference: Reza Aslan Author of "There is no god but God"
Secularism = seperation of church and state
Democracy = government by the people; rule of the majority
Secularism is in itself an ideology, almost a new religion. Take for example in America, the various laws in regards to homosexuality, and gay marriage. Another example would be the secular state of Turkey, where the ideology is to force Muslim women not to wear Hijab, if it was truely secular, this ideology would not interefere with the individual's beliefs.
Pluralism: A state that is based on the freedom to practice ones beliefs without hinderance. A pluralistic society would be based on the majority rule, but the majority of each group would be represented.
How does Islam fit? Islam is a system of pluralism not secularism, which means that Islam creates justice for all, Jews, Christians, Hindus, etc. Under Islamlic law, people that are not Muslims are protected, and can rule themselves by their own laws, the only stipulation is a protection tax, which is only applicable in an Islamicly run country. The fundemental belief in Islam is that there is no compulsion in religion.
Can Islam have democracy? Islam is the rule of God, but the rule is for the people. So yes Islam can have democracy, but not a democracy that is based on the rule of the majority, it must always contain the rule of God.
How can we implement democracy in Islamic countries? First, Americans can not and should not expect to implement American democracy in any foriegn coutry. Democracy must evolve from within the country itself, it can not be inherited from another country. The reason being that American democracy has its roots in Judao-Christian beliefs, and although Islam is based on a similar Abrahamic faith, it can not inherit democratic values from America, it must develop it's own, having its roots in Islamic beliefs, otherwise it will be rejected by the people, and it will never work.

No comments:
Post a Comment